I have been neglecting you, my Faithful Five blog readers. I’m so sorry about that.
Writing-wise, I’m in a good space these days, busy working on this collection about the Sibley sisters that I’ve set at the turn of the 20th Century. I don’t have many poems yet, and a few of the ones I have are struggling with problematic last stanzas or are trying to do too much on a single page–which is to say, sometimes you can be too ambitious for one poor piece of paper, and you can’t fit it all. Neither of these issues is keeping me down though, and it’s not like I’m up against a deadline–though I’d be pretty happy if I was near-to-done by the end of the year, so I could enter it in the 2011 contest cycle.
Now while I’ve just said I’m not down about the “too much poem for one page” bit, I realize that’s totally disingenuous. The fact is, it is difficult sometimes to write narrative poetry because you have a lot of the issues that you’d have in writing a novel–I mean, you have to have scene, character, setting, plot, and Aristotelian dramatic structure–but you need to do it in a confined space. This ain’t easy. I’m sure I’m taking liberties here, but Blake Leland (who, frankly, knows more about poetry than God) has a theory that if you have to turn the page to continue reading a poem, anything on the second page is doomed and/ or no damn good, and I tend to agree with him. I gotta love a poem a whole lot if I have to turn the page to continue reading it–otherwise the “tldr phenomenon” response kicks in. So, with that caveat in mind, I’ve been trying to keep each poem on a single manuscript page.
The truth is, though, an 8×11 sheet of paper is not the same as a book page–so probably most of these poems are going to take up more than one page anyway, if only by a few lines, which is unfortunate–there’s nothing worse to me, aesthetically, than a page in a book with only 2 lines on it. Which brings up another point–is this artificial one-page requirement serving the best interest of the poems overall? Can the demands of narrative poetry be served by the single page, or does that curtail creativity and the full exploration of what the poem wants to present? In other words, is fitting everything into one page unnecesarily acrobatic?
I have no doubt that I will, at some point, have to write a multi-page poem–possibly, a very long central poem, and maybe the titular one (though I don’t have a title yet)–so I don’t want to lessen the impact of that poem by having a lot of longish other poems in the collection. I don’t want people–especially the Pulitzer Prize committee ;-)–tossing my book across the room in disgust because their eyes are tired of long poems, and they want a damn lyric already, you know?
It’s a weird tension, because at the core of this issue really is the reader’s attention span. I’ll you what, when we were reading Brightwood in class, I did get a little irritated with how long some of R.T. Smith’s poems were. I like shortness–that’s why I’m a poet and not a novelist–and I tend to think most readers’ expectation is that they’ll get in and out of a poem pretty fast. That’s part of the pleasure of poetry–it’s that crystallized moment of literary purity–and then it’s done.
I don’t know that I can resolve this concern about ideal page length and reader’s aesthetics, other than to remind myself that it is my book, and I can kind of do what I want (as long as the DYPS think the poems are working at whatever length the poems turn out to be). It’s early yet in the collection–who’s to say I won’t write a lot of short ones in the upcoming months?
I suppose I’ve been dithering over something less important than what actually IS the main concern–and that is, I don’t really have an arc yet. I don’t really know where these poems are going, other than a kind of nebulous pseudo Southern Gothic end in mind. I’m not writing the poems in chronological order–which is quite liberating in some ways, and troublesome in others. And the main characters haven’t totally revealed themselves to me; I’m sort of learning about them as I write poems about their lives.
But, it’s breakfast time, and I’m too hungry to worry about the Grand Scheme of Things, at least as they pertain to the Sibley sisters, right now.
A reader who is following a long entwined narrative of book or chapbook length isn’t going to worry so much about moving on from the individual poem. Length is an asset in narrative poetry.
PS If the Pulitzer Prize Committee wants short, send them my way.
JC…is that the Sibley sisters who were the first women bank officers in Atlanta? If so, my cousin’s husband is writing a novel (or has already completed it) about them. He’s up in Dunwoody section and teaches writing at Kennessaw. I believe he still does; he’s an attorney by day. Neil Wilkerson…
And, I know nothing about the professional rules for poetry publishing but I have made a two-column page on some of my Christmas poems which are longer. Is that allowed? It would certainly solve the problem of losing the train of thought on a carry-over two lines of a great poem which yours assuredly always are…
My only hard & fast rule is “Don’t write crappy poems” — and yet, even that one I can’t help but break…
Really enjoyed that trip through your writing thoughts, JC!
I’ve missed your blog. I’m sure you have WAY MORE than five readers.
I don’t mind turning the page “as long as it’s good.” 😉
I greatly enjoyed today lingering over your blog.
You are very inspirational, very deep in thought with many of the same thoughts flowing with concerns, frights of how many pages etc.
Write, write, write each day and see where it goes. Aim not for fitting in to the one page limit. You would be amazed of those that will read with delight beyond of one page.
Let your imagination run free, give it permission to explore, throw off the collar and chain and free yourself to be. Your writing will flow, linger in that creative space we know well. The words seem to transport themselves to the page where we read and then go back and look and ask, did I write this?
You have what it takes, believe, trust, give yourself permission to fly freely, then go for it right now! Time is wasting away.
I look forward to reading more of your writing very soon.
Many smiles to brighten the dark moments when doubt lingers with of your midst.